HomeNew YorkLong Eddy › Handsome Hollow

Handsome Hollow

4.6 ★★★★★ 76 Google reviews · Barn wedding venue in Long Eddy, New York

Weddings

Picturesque property with a barn and farmhouse that caters to weddings, plus friendly staff.

Plan your tour

The setting

The style of Handsome Hollow in couples' own words — pulled from their reviews and the venue's own info, not guessed from the photos.

🌸 Gardens & Grounds 4 mentions

“The number one thing our family, friends, and guests talked about and complimented was Handsome Hollow and how beautiful, peaceful, and magical the grounds were.”

All gardens & grounds venues →

Amenities couples mention

Amenities couples name in their reviews of Handsome Hollow — the fastest way to tell what the venue actually offers before you drive out for a tour.

🛏️ On-Site Lodging

“Staying in the guest house was fantastic.”

More venues with on-site lodging →

Outdoor Ceremony Site

More venues with outdoor ceremony site →

💡 String Lights

“The barn is a beautiful reception space that's open, inviting, and even more magical after sunset under the glowing string lights!”

More venues with string lights →

🔥 Fire Pit

“They also light the fire pit for you and provide large adirondack chairs.”

More venues with fire pit →

⛰️ Scenic Views

“The barn is a beautiful reception space that's open, inviting, and even more magical after sunset under the glowing string lights!”

More venues with scenic views →

Amenity mentions are mined from reviews and the venue's own info — they tell you what couples found on the grounds, not what's included in every package. Confirm what comes with your date when you tour.

What couples say again and again

The things reviewers bring up again and again across 76 Google reviews — with their own words as proof.

stunning venue & grounds 48 mentions

“The number one thing our family, friends, and guests talked about and complimented was Handsome Hollow and how beautiful, peaceful, and magical the grounds were.”

🤝 owners who go above & beyond 3 mentions

“Kate, Huck, and their whole team went above and beyond to make sure we had everything we needed and kept our events running smoothly.”

📋 day-of coordination 7 mentions

“It is the most perfect atmosphere (it’s something out of a magazine) to get ready in on the day of with you girls and family.”

📸 photo-perfect backdrops 3 mentions

“In addition, Handsome Hollow has a stunning "Ruins" area with an earthly and beautiful stone wall backdrop.”

🚗 easy for out-of-town guests 2 mentions

From the reviews

Having our wedding at Handsome Hollow was an absolute dream. Kate and her team are professional, thorough, and beyond helpful before and on the day of the wedding. The location and grounds are stunning! We chose to have our ceremony in the fern forest a little ways up from the barn - it's like walking into a fairytale.

★★★★★ — Dave, Aug 2024

Handsome Hollow was our dream venue for so many reasons, and we are so happy with our choice. Logistically, they were one of the only outdoor venues we spoke to that had a viable and lovely rain plan (so many places told us to rent a tent or hope for the best...) which was a huge plus as we were doing a spring wedding.

★★★★★ — Hannah, Jul 2025

It's always a pleasure to work at Handsome Hollow. Kate and Huck have done a fabulous job with the venue and keep it in top notch condition. There are so many possibilities for customizing a wedding there. We love designing the space for weddings. See some of our photos. we highly recommend this venue to couples.

★★★★★ — Angela, Dec 2016

HH is a venue with beauty that is otherworldly and Kate and Huck are so professional, hospitable, and on top of their game, that all of your wedding dreams will come true if you choose HH. The Grounds- HH is breathtaking.

★★★★★ — Taylor, Jun 2019

Excerpts from public Google reviews. Read all 76 reviews →

Getting married at Handsome Hollow

Handsome Hollow comes up for weddings — confirmed on their own site. Two things make the tour worth the drive. First, see it at the time of day you'd actually get married — a barn that glows at golden hour can feel very different at noon, and you'll want to walk the path your guests take from parking to ceremony to reception. Second, bring your real questions: the rain plan (where does the ceremony move?), the catering and bar policy, the music curfew, and exactly what's included with the rental — tables, chairs, setup, and teardown are where quotes quietly diverge. Popular dates at barn venues book 12–18 months out, so if the tour feels right, ask what's open in your season before you leave.

See their weddings page

Where to find Handsome Hollow

5256 Co Rd 28, Long Eddy, NY12760

Get directions Instagram

More barn venues near Long Eddy

Long Hill Farm

5 ★★★★★ 2 reviews

156 Bauernfeind Rd, Callicoon, NY

Weddings stunning venue & groundsphoto-perfect backdropsguests raved about it

13.1 miles away

The Barn on Hubbard

4.6 ★★★★★ 25 reviews

28 Hubbard Rd, Callicoon, NY

Weddings All-inclusive stunning venue & groundsday-of coordinationgreat value

14.8 miles away

Valley View Farm & Venue

5 ★★★★★ 12 reviews

72 Valley Ridge Rd, Honesdale, PA

Weddings stunning venue & groundsowners who go above & beyondphoto-perfect backdrops

19.0 miles away

All barn venues near Long Eddy, NY →

Listing verified July 2026 from public business records and couples' reviews. Something out of date? Report a correction. Own this venue? Claim your listing — it's free.